Tuesday, 8 March 2016

WARNING TO ALL THOSE TRADING AS ESTATE AGENTS AND THE PUBLIC

By Mfundisi
8th March 2016

In the case of Austin Banda trading as Land Sales & Property Transfers V Stephen Leonard Aipila (Commercial Case No 28 of 2015, Lilongwe), Justice Mtalimanja has delivered a well reason judgement that ought to be taken as a warning to Malawians, especially those who are involved in land transactions, either as estate agents or lawyers or as sellers or buyers of land or fixed properties. This post provides a commentary of the case and draws out excerpts which contain what I view to be the key findings and statements that the court makes. In terms of style, I have extracted paragraphs from the judgement and below each paragraph provided a commentary. The commentary is in Italic and has Com: at the beginning. I have deliberately used different fonts to distinguish my commentary with the words of the judge. The excerpts from the judgement are preceded by a paragraph number.

BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE FACTS OF THE CASE
The plaintiff, an estate agent sued the defendant for the sum of K2.8 million being 10% commission of a sale of property transaction, damages for breach of contract and costs of the action. The defendant, who was the owner of the property sold denied liability for the plaintiff’s claim in its entirety and prayed that the claim be dismissed with costs.

The court then went on to consider the evidence in detail as well as the applicable law. The court found that the evidence disclosed that there was an agency agreement between the Plaintiff and the Defendant and that the Plaintiff would have otherwise been entitled to his 10% commission [paragraph 56]. We start off after the court has analysed the evidence and start making its findings:
----------------------------------------

55. The defendant conceded that the plaintiff advised him right at the outset that he will charge an estate agency commission of 10% of the sale price of the property. The plaintiff contends that the defendant accepted this condition. PW 2 testified that he informed the defendant that the plaintiff charges a commission of 10% of the purchase price for his services of identifying buyers for clients. PW4 also testified that he informed the defendant that the plaintiff will charge a commission of 10% of the purchase price and the defendant accepted this.

56. I am persuaded by and do believe these pieces of testimony and find that the defendant was duly informed prior to the transactions that the plaintiff will charge him a commission of 10% of the purchase price for his services of identifying a buyer on his behalf. As I have already found, there was an agency relationship between the plaintiff and the defendant. But for the observations below, the plaintiff would have been entitled to receive 10% commission of the K28 million, as consideration for the estate agent services he rendered to the defendant in the agency relationship.
---------------------------
Com: The defendant was disputing that there was an agency agreement between the parties. Here in paragraph the Court is making a finding that there was. The Court then says that it would have awarded the Plaintiff his claim were it not for the findings of illegality that follow. In other words, were the Plaintiff a properly registered agent, he would have won the case hands down.
-----------------------------

64. The law (Section 3 of the Land Economy Surveyors, Valuers, Estate Agents and Auctioneers Act, Act No. 5 of 1989) provides that:
“(1) ... no person shall practise under any name, title or style containing the words land economy surveyor, valuer, estate agent or auctioneer, for the purpose of gain, make any other use of such name, title or style, unless he is registered under the Act as a land economy surveyor, valuer, estate agent or auctioneer,
(2) any person who contravenes this section commits an offence and is liable upon conviction, to a fine of K2000 and to imprisonment for 1 year.”.
---------------------------
Com: This means that unless a person is registered under the Act cited above as an estate agent, that person is committing an offence if he purports to act as an agent without registration. He can be charged with a criminal offence.
-----------------------------

65. Section 8 of the Land Economy Act outlines the qualifications for registration in any of the specified capacities. In terms of this section no person is eligible for registration as an estate agent unless he either has attained the age of 22 years, has passed a qualifying examination approved by the Board of Registration and has not less than 2 years post qualification practical experience or articled pupillage in the work of an estate agent. If not, the person shall satisfy the Board that he possesses a qualification which in the opinion of the Board furnishes a sufficient guarantee of the possession of the requisite knowledge and skill for the efficient practice of the work of an estate agent.
---------------------------
Com: The above provides qualifications for one to be registered as an estate agent. As can be seen, not every Dokiso and Mangaliso can qualify. They need to sit and pass for a qualifying examination and must have 2 years of post-qualification practical experience or be under pupillage of a registered estate agent. However the law allows those who have not sat for an examination but do possess a qualification which in the opinion of the Board of Registration is sufficient for that person to practice.
-----------------------------

66. In my understanding, the requirement for registration under the Act is not merely for purposes of revenue collection by the State. As the long title of the Land Economy Act shows, the object of this legislation is to provide for the registration, regulation and control of land economy surveyors, valuers, estate agents and auctioneers. The provision of qualification requirements shows that the intention of the legislature was to regulate and control the practice of the work of an estate agent (as well as the other categories) so that not every other person should practice as such without the Board ascertaining that that person is suitably qualified. Section 8 ensures that only those persons deemed qualified by the Board after satisfying the conditions get to be registered.
---------------------------
Com: Here the court is saying the purposes of registration is not for revenue collection only but to also ensure that only qualified and registered agents are allowed to transact in land transactions. In other words, the reason for registration are:
1.    To ensure that the registered estate agents pay the requisite fees as well as tax
2.    Protection of all people dealing in land transactions
-----------------------------

68. The testimony of all the witnesses herein establishes that the defendant instructed the plaintiff, in the capacity of an estate agent, to find potential buyers for the property. The evidence further shows that the plaintiff accepted and performed the instructions and is now claiming payment for the work so performed as an estate agent. Clearly the plaintiff held himself out and operated as an estate agent for gain, notwithstanding the fact that he is not duly registered under the Land Economy Act. I therefore find that the plaintiff was practicing as an estate agent in contravention of the Act. Further, I find that the plaintiff entered into the agency agreement here in issue with the defendant in the capacity of an estate agent without being registered as such.
---------------------------
Com: The evidence has shown that the Plaintiff was not a registered estate agent according to law and had no power to act as an agent for the plaintiff in this matter. Put simply he was doing so illegally.
-----------------------------


Conclusion
76. From the foregoing, I find that the agency agreement between the plaintiff and the defendant was illegal for contravening statute and was therefore void ab initio. The plaintiff cannot enforce it. I therefore dismiss the plaintiff’s action in its entirety.
---------------------------
Com: This means that this is an illegal contract. The Court cannot enforce an illegal act. In other words, the Plaintiff has lost the case.
-----------------------------

77. The outcome of this matter has greatly exercised my mind. I am mindful of the sense of moral injustice that the plaintiff is likely to feel about being precluded by the law from recovering fees for services duly rendered to the defendant. However, as per the words of Lord Mansfield in the case of Holman v Johnson(1775) 1 Cowp 341 at 343, where he said that:
“The objection, that the contract is immoral or illegal as between the plaintiff and defendant sounds at all times very ill in the mouth of the defendant. It is not for his sake, however, that the objection is ever allowed; but it is found in general principles of policy, which the defendant has advantage of, contrary to the real justice, as between him and the plaintiff, by accident if I may so say. The principle of public policy is this; ex dolo malo non oritur actio. No Court will lend its aid to a man who founds his cause of action upon an immoral or illegal act. If, from the plaintiff’s own stating or otherwise, the cause of action appear to arise ex turpi causa, or the transgression of a positive law of this country, then the Court says he has no right to be assisted. It is upon that ground the Court goes; not for the sake of the defendant, but because they will not lend their aid to such a plaintiff. So if the plaintiff and defendant were to change sides, and the defendant was to bring his action against the plaintiff, the latter would then have the advantage of it; for where both are equally in fault potior est conditio defendentis”.
---------------------------
Com: Here the court is lamenting that there is in a sense moral injustice to the Plaintiff in that he did indeed do his part and ordinarily should be paid for his labour. However, the law is clear that no action can arise from an illegal action or an illegality. The Court quotes from an old case [the older the better in law as it shows it has withstood the test of time] in which the judge in that case encountered a similar moral dilemma. But as the Court puts it: “No Court will lend its aid to a man who founds his cause of action upon an immoral or illegal act.” In other words, once the Court finds that the Plaintiff acted illegality, the Court will throw away the claim even if it would have otherwise succeeded on the facts. The reason of doing this is not to reward illegality.
-----------------------------

78. Further, I must for the record state that I take notice of the fact that the real property industry in Malawi has witnessed an observable boom in recent years, and this has in turn led to the mushrooming of many Land Economy Surveyors, Valuers, Estate Agents and Auctioneers especially in the major cities here in Malawi. This Court hopes that, unlike the plaintiff herein, all these are duly registered under the Land Economy Act and are operating lawfully in the country, principally for two reasons. Firstly, for the protection of the public from persons practicing in the specified categories without the requisite qualifications. Secondly, that they will not have to one day undergo the rather unfortunate experience of the plaintiff in the instant matter in being barred from enforcing a claim for payment of services duly rendered.

---------------------------
Com: Here the court is sounding a warning and putting it on record for posterity. The warning is to other estate agents practising as well as the general population, having taken judicial notice of their boom. The Court expresses the hope that the other estate agents practising their trade are duly registered because if they are not they are operating illegally.

The Court says that the law is firstly protecting the public from person who are not qualified to practice (some of them may be unscrupulous and may not have an idea of what they are doing). Secondly it is advice to estate agents that they should avoid zimene awona anzawo mu case imeneyi.
-----------------------------

In conclusion then, the Plaintiff lost his case because he was acting illegally. From an illegal action, no right at law can accrue, that is the law. The court’s warning is therefore timely to all of us. How many adverts do we see of estate agents advertising for properties? These adverts are in the papers, on Facebook, almost on every media that is accessible to the public. For the avoidance of doubt, the warning is to:
1.    The general public to be generally aware
2.    Those who are selling property. Make sure you are dealing with registered agents. Demand proof of registration and the registration must be current
3.    Those buying property. As above, demand proof.
4.    Lawyers engaged in transfer of title. As above, demand proof.
5.    Those transacting as estate agents - if you are not registered you are acting illegally and breaking the law. At best you cannot enforce any claim for a commission as was the case here. At worst you may be arrested and charged with an offence. Remember ignorance of the law is no defence. If you hold yourself out as an agent, you will be deemed to know the requirements of an agent. Forewarned is forearmed.


The Court is doing this to ensure it protects everyone; the buyers, the sellers as well as the estate agents themselves. As it is said, the law may appear to be slow in its action. However the long arm of the law will eventually catch up with you. Never be fooled; the wheels of justice may grind slowly, but the surely do grind. And when you are in the path of the grinding law; there can only be one winner; the law.

Saturday, 27 February 2016

THE WEEK OF CONTRADICTIONS

By Mfundisi
27 February 2016

Let me start by saying upfront that I consider treason to be a serious offence. However I qualify what treason is. In this regard, I have problems with the law as it stands that tends to include mere trivialities in the realm of treason. In my view treason should be limited to provable cases of armed insurrection, coups or toppling a lawfully instituted government by use of armed force. In my view calls for ‘regime change’ per se can never be treason, unless it is effected by unlawful means as described above. That said, treason-wise, the past week has been an interesting one on many; full of contradictions. Even the most serious among us would struggle not to find a moment of laughter in what has been what in drama we would call a ‘tragi-com’ (mixture of tragedy and comedy).

It all started when the nation woke up to the fact that 3 members of the Malawi Congress Party (MCP) top brass, Ulemu Msungama, Dr Jessie Kabwila and Louis Chakhwantha were being sought on allegation of plotting a coup against the lawfully instituted government of Malawi.[1] The latter two are members of parliament (MPs). Indeed one by one the named three soon found themselves in Police custody. Let us start at the beginning, always very good place to start.[2] Msungama was the first to be arrested. The media reported that he had been charged by the Police with sedition and released.[3] And that led to the first contradiction as the bail bond that Msungama obtained indicated a charge of treason. But we will get to that later.

So after the release of Msungama over the reported sedition charges, the logical conclusion was that if the charged emanated from the same WhatsApp discussion, then Kabwila and Chakhwantha would also be charged with the same offence of sedition. And that is where the dancing started.

I and some legal scholars were quoted in an online publication providing our personal views about sedition in these modern times.[4] Essentially the arguments being raised were that sedition was inconsistent with the present Constitutional dispensation and should be repealed. Now before people go up in arms it is important to reflect back. Where did we get our sedition laws from? This was a law that was brought in as part of the colonial legacy. Now in 2010, the colonial masters, themselves decided to abolish this old common law offence. The United Kingdom’s Justice Minister Claire Ward said ‘Sedition and seditious and defamatory libel are arcane offences – from a bygone era when freedom of expression wasn’t seen as the right it is today.’[5] To this statement, I think I can add nothing, she said it all. It is a relic of a bygone era, with no place in the modern world. I and others were simply saying it is time we did the same.

Yours truly had also earlier made a social media comment regarding the decision of Justice Chikopa in Republic v Harry Mkandawire and Yeremiah Chihana.[6] In that case, these are the words that Chikopa J used: ‘perhaps it is time we decided whether in their present form our sedition laws remain valid in the current Constitutional dispensation or whether we still need them. We think not in either instance.’ In my view, the High Court in the case invalidated our seditions laws. If that view is correct, any sedition charge would meet a legal hurdle in a court of law. If the trial court were to agree with my view, then the charge would be thrown out altogether as being invalid. The power of the High Court to invalidate a law comes under the Constitution.[7] Now others disagreed with me and argued that the High Court did not actually invalidate the law but merely expressed a wish. To this my response was that Judges are not birthday boys and girls. Judicial officers make no wishes. They are not in the business of offering advice. Their word is a command. Judges order and their order is law. My understanding therefore of Justice Chikopa’s judgement is that the High Court decided that sedition laws under the Penal Code as they stand are unconstitutional and therefore invalid. That case was not appealed. The Malawi Supreme Court of Appeal has not overruled this case in any subsequence case that I am aware of. Therefore the law as it stands is that in their present form, our sedition laws are invalid in the current Constitutional dispensation. Legally speaking therefore, unless and until this decision is overruled, it remains law. That is how the law operates.

This raised a controversy. I was alerted to a jibe that a fellow lawyer had made at me and others that I was trying to confuse the population. I was being accused of declaring a law that is on the statute book invalid on social media and attempting to get media mileage from my posts. It was also said that I was a mere academic and not a practitioner so what did I know?  Now as a teacher, one gets accustomed to such jibes from people. And for the record I am both an academic and a practitioner. In fact I teach practical courses, something that requires possession of a legal practical licence. It is however, important that what I said be understood for what it meant. For starters, I have no power to declare any law invalid. Whom am I but a mere mfundisi? But one thing I can confidently say is that I know that when a High Court in Malawi makes a decision, it is law unless overruled. Now let us be clear, when a High Court declares a law invalid that does not by some magic operation amend the letters of the law in the statute books as they stand. The words in the Penal Code, for example, still remain as they were printed. There is no magic wand to miraculously amend them. It is up to Parliament to formally repeal the law. In practice, any invalidated law under the Constitution is no longer law.  What is means is that whenever a person is reading that part of the law, they must bear in mind what the High Court decided. Did the High Court in R v Mkandawire and Chihana declare sedition laws invalid? I would say yes it did. Is it possible that I could be wrong? Yes it is possible, and that is the beauty of law. The fact that I say this is my understanding of the law does not mean it is the only true understanding of the law. It may be right, but it may equally be wrong. No one has a monopoly of wisdom. What matters is what one believes in and the reasons for doing so. I believe the High Court invalidated the law because the High Court has that power under the Constitution. Is it possible that the words of Justice Chikopa did not mean what I think they did? It is possible indeed. Language by its nature is capable of being interpreted in many ways. However, having been an avid Chikopa scholar, and followed his style of writing, I am convinced that the High Court invalidated the sedition laws. Now others have raised an issue that the question of sedition was never really before the judge and therefore he decided outside the boundaries of the case. That may indeed be so, but the way the law works is that unless and until another Court or a superior Court makes that determination, the decision of the Court is still binding and law. That is how the Common Law legal system works. In summary therefore, yours truly did not declare any law invalid. I have no such power. Neither was I seeking any so-called media mileage. For what utility may I ask? I was merely expressing my views on my Facebook wall and some of those views were picked on by the media, something I have no control over. If the media decided to quote me, what could poor mfundisi do?

But let us come back to the case involving the so-called WhatsApp coup plotters. It was reported that the Police wanted to effect an arrest of the two within the precincts of Parliament. And that a road-block was mounted for this purpose. It was further reported that this was angrily rebuffed when opposition members actually walked out, dismantled the so-called roadblock and confronted the Police who wisely, in my view, drove off. The online version of the Nation Newspaper provided a video of what went down at the Parliament square.[8] It is stuff only seen in movies! Now there has been a lot of talk whether MPs were entitled to confront the Police. This would depend whether the Police were entitled to be within the precincts of Parliament in the first place for the purposes of arresting an MP. Under the common law, a person is entitled to resist an unlawful arrest.[9] Under law, MPs are immune from arrest while going to, returning from or while within the precincts of Parliament unless on a treason charge.[10] Therefore on the basis that Msungama had been charged with sedition, if the same charge were to be proffered against Kabwila and Chakhwantha, then the Police had no jurisdiction to arrest the two while Parliament was sitting. Now this should not be mistaken with a blanket immunity given to MPs. That is not what the law is saying. The law merely provides a temporary reprieve from arrest to MPs while Parliament is sitting. However, there is a proviso in the Constitution, and that is unless the person is charged with treason. In other words, for all other offences, the arrest can pend. That does not in any way affect the execution of any warrant of arrest after Parliament rises.

The media reported that Kabwila then sought to seek refuge at the German Embassy and was arrested at the gate. Another question arises. Was Kabwila arrested within the precincts of the German Embassy? If so, then this is against the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Immunity.[11] Under the said Convention, the ‘premises of the [foreign] mission shall be inviolable. The agents of the [host] State may not enter them, except with the consent of the head of the mission.’[12] So depending on where exactly the arrest was effected, there may be an issue here. However, luckily we have an answer to this. According to MCP’s Ezekiel Ching’oma, Kabwila ‘was picked outside Ministry of Tourism offices, which are near the German Embassy.’[13] This therefore would rule out any contravention of the Vienna Convention on the part of Malawi regarding this incident.

On the premise that the charge was sedition, yours truly among other legal scholars cautioned that the Police could not validly execute any arrest of the two while Parliament was sitting. Furthermore that if indeed any such arrest was effected, it would be unconstitutional and unlawful. Others however, wrongly construed this a backing of the persons who were being sought by the Police. The counter-argument being offered was that Kabwila and Chakhwantha were being sought for treason. Now this would contradict the information that Msungama was charged with sedition. However it is not inconceivable that several persons may be charged with different offences depending on their role in an alleged criminal enterprise. At this time however, the so-called treason discussion on WhatsApp had gone viral and was all over social media. People made their own interpretation of the discussions. Most laughed them off. However, even if treason was what the MPs were being sought for, this still presented a problem. While the immunity of MPs could be lifted over a charge of treason, the charge must be a real and bona fide charge. It must be arrived at when the State has prima facie evidence that treason or attempts to commit treason have been made. I would differentiate a charge of treason being made in order to facilitate an arrest and a situation where the facts point to treason. In my view the arrest would only be legal in the latter scenario. Therefore it does not lie with the Police to arrest the two MPs on a treason charge unless the charge is backed up with credible evidence on their part. As will be seen later, the Police did not have such evidence. In my view, having read the leaked WhatsApp thread, from my understanding of the law, I would think this would require more than the chit chat that I read to charge a person with treason. Yes the discussion did show that certain person had been having private discussion over the political situation in Malawi with some of them proposing rather radical ideas. Did I form an opinion regarding the discussion? Of course I did. But largely I dismissed it as the usual talk of people not happy with a certain state of affairs. In other words I was dismissive of the thread, especially considering that they all belong to one political party and are all politically active. I however did question the illogical flow of posts. I had a lot of questions I must admit. But I am no prosecutor and my lens may be biased. It also possible that the State had and has other evidence apart from the leaked WhatsApp messages.

Anyway Kabwila was eventually released on bail but after being charged with treason by the Police.[14] Now this raised another set of contradictions and controversies. For starters, the Police in Malawi prosecute criminal suspects as proxies of the Director of Public Prosecution (DPP). Only the DPP is empowered to prosecute criminal offences in Malawi. Any prosecution by the Police are therefore on behalf of the DPP through delegated powers.[15] Now only the DPP can proffer treason charges. The Police have no jurisdiction to proffer a charge of treason. Treason offences are triable only in the High Court. The penalty for a conviction of treason is death. As such only the High Court can release a person charged with treason on bail. Police bail for treason suspects is therefore a contradiction in itself.

Chakhwantha who had meanwhile sought refuge at the German Embassy decided to hand himself over to the Police where he was arrested and also charged with treason and also later released.[16] In other words, all three were arrested, ‘charged’ with treason and released on Police bail. Since I have not been privy to the contents of the bail conditions of Kabwila and Chakhwantha, I cannot comment on these but I can comment on Msungama. It transpired that Msungama had not been charged with sedition as reported but rather with treason.  This was evident in a copy of the bail bond that also went viral and indicated that the he had been released on his own surety. Now I recall when I raised the oddity of first the Police charging a person with treason and then releasing that on own surety, a colleague simply remarked: ‘just shows you the whole thing is a masquerade. Keep watching, I am sure the charade will get more exciting before it meets its death.’ And how right he was.

Now it is not uncommon for a person to be released on their own surety. It is however, virtually impossible where treason is concerned. The State would want to be assured that the person would attend trial. But then that leads to the original contradiction. But first things first. The Police has no jurisdiction to charge a person with treason. The term charge is a legal term.  Person maybe informed what he is suspected of having committed but the charge is only proffered against the suspect in a court of law. Of course sometimes a person maybe charged with what is termed a ‘holding charge’ which is essentially a charge that the evidence so far reveals but where the State actually thinks investigations may lead to a more serious charge. Therefore for the avoidance of doubt, the charges that the Police make to suspects who have been arrested are not real charges. The real charges are the ones that are made in court. But indeed there is nothing wrong in informing a person of the charge they are likely to face or the charge they are suspected of having committed. Therefore the real charge that matters is the formal charge as this is the one which a person has to answer to before a court of law.[17] In terms of procedure, a person charged with treason would be taken to a Magistrate court where they would thereafter be committed to the High Court. This is because a Magistrate Court has no jurisdiction in Malawi over treason cases.[18]

Now remember I remarked how colleague was in saying the charade was not over yet? The Inspector General (IG) of Police decided to address a press conference, bringing the whole charade to a full circle.  For starters, in Malawi the IG is not in the habit of addressing press conferences. He leaves this to his communications officers. So when he does, it means he has something serious to convey, especially if in doing so he seemingly contradicts the official Police spokesperson. The IG stated that the Police ‘has no evidence for treason charges levelled against [the] three MCP officials.’[19] He indicated that the Police have not formally charged the three because there is no evidence of treason but insisted that the Police are still investigating to establish if the suspects have a case to answer’.[20] Well in the first place it is once again a case of misuse of terms. In the first place, the Police cannot formally charge anyone with treason and secondly the determination of whether a person has a case to answer is made by the Court after the prosecution has finished parading its witnesses and evidence. But other than that, the Police IG was spot on.

Now according to Nyasatimes, the official Police Spokesperson had earlier said the three were given sedition as ‘holding charges’ and then pressed with treason after recording their statements as formal charges.[21] Now if this is true, the arrest of the MCP officials was premised on sedition and the issues of treason only arose after recording their statement. This then contradictory to what we were told at first, which is that the three were being sought for treason. It once again it rekindles the debate of whether the arrest of Kabwila and Chakhwantha were lawful. If the Spokesperson is right, I would argue that the arrest were unconstitutional and unlawful. It violated Parliament’s sanctity. Another statement attributed to the Police Spokesperson is interesting if not outright contradictory: that sedition and treason are ‘interrelated’.[22] This is the first time I have heard this. In fact I should be forthright and say that this is not correct. Sedition and treason are not interrelated. Related offences are called akin offences. Sedition is not an akin offence to treason and neither is the vice versa true.
The Police Chief is further quoted to have said three were not formally charged and only caution statements were taken.[23] In this the Police IG is right and setting the record right. I may just add that the task of formally charging them is outside the jurisdiction of the Police anyway. It is at the court that this would be done. The Police chief also said investigations are ongoing. Indeed for such a serious offence such as treason, it is only fair and just that thorough investigation be done by the Police.

Now while the drama of the arrests was being played out, Speaker of the National Assembly on Tuesday decided to adjourn the house early amid security concerns and sought assurances from the government[24] The government quickly reacted through Leader of Government in Parliament, assuring the Parliament that the government would assure immunity of MPs from arrests at Parliament, conceding that there was violation of the parliamentary immunity. [25] It therefore begs the question, are the arrests valid in view of this? Only time will tell.

But maybe the last word goes to Presidential spokesperson Gerald Viola whose view on this I would opine is reflective of the majority of Malawians. Asked if President Mutharika takes the WhatsApp conversations serious he replied: “No no no no, the President is not moved because he knows that in Malawi the person is given the position of the president through a vote, so he is not intimidated. He is just probably laughing at the matters that were discussed,”[26]

Considering the way the issue has been discussed over social media I would say the President is not the only one laughing over the whole episode. Even Fingo and Puludzu have had field days over it. I have also heard of an audio recording which left me in stitches, referring to a ‘reason’ offence and that it was just a ‘warning arrest’. Would that maybe also explain why MBC-TV decide to ‘parade’ the WhatsApp evidence on national television? I mean ordinarily in a serious case of treason, this would be unheard of. It would not only prove a hurdle for the prosecution but any court seized with the matter would not kindly look at such conduct. But maybe it is all part of the ‘not taking it seriously’. What an exciting charade, what a week. Never a dull moment in the country of ours.
But maybe the last word is to the Police. Do not forget that the IG is always confirmed by the whole parliament. Please do not make the conformation hard for subsequent IGs. Take this under advisement.



[1] Alfred Chauwa, ‘Kabwila faces arrest for ‘treason’ over Whatsapp discussion: Malawi opposition aide accused of inciting ‘regime change’’ Nyasatimes, 21 February, 2016 available at http://www.nyasatimes.com/2016/02/21/kabwila-faces-arrest-for-treason-over-whatsapp-discussion-malawi-opposition-aide-accused-of-inciting-regime-change/
[2] A famous line from the movie Sound of Music.
[3][3] Thom Chiumia, ‘Uladi storms Malawi Police station in ‘solidarity’” Msungama charged with sedition’ Nyasatimes, 22 February, 2016. http://www.nyasatimes.com/2016/02/22/uladi-storms-malawi-police-station-in-solidarity-msungama-charged-with-sedition/ also see Suzgo Khunga ‘Msungama charged, out on bail’ The Nation, 23 February, 2016 available at http://mwnation.com/nsungama-charged-out-on-bail/
[4] Thom Chiumia , ‘Malawi sedition law ‘declared invalid’: Law scholars discuss inconsistencies’ Nyasatimes 23 February 2016 available at http://www.nyasatimes.com/2016/02/23/malawi-sedition-laws-declared-invalid-law-scholars-discuss-inconsistencies/
[5] ‘Criminal libel and sedition offences abolished’ Pressgazette 13 January 2010 available at http://www.pressgazette.co.uk/node/44884
[6] Criminal cause No. 5 of 2010, High Court, Mzuzu Registry.
[8] Jacob Nankhonya, ‘Watch the drama at Parliament as Kabwila got arrested’ The Nation 23 February 2016 available at http://mwnation.com/watch-the-drama-at-parliament-as-kabwila-got-arrested/
[9] John Bad Elk v. United States, 177 U.S. 529 (1900)
[10] Section 60(1), Constitution of the Republic of Malawi
[11] Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations (1961) available at http://legal.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/conventions/9_1_1961.pdf
[12] Article 22(1), Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations (1961)
[13] Macdonald Thom ‘Drama over Jessie Kabwila’s arrest’ Daily Times 23 February 2016 available at http://www.times.mw/drama-over-jessie-kabwilas-arrest/
[14] ‘Jessie Kabwila charged with treason’ Daily Times 23 February 2016 available at http://www.times.mw/jessie-kabwila-charged-with-treason/
[15] Section 100 (1) Constitution of the Republic of Malawi.
[16] Richard Jimu ‘Chakhwantha out on bail’ Malawi24 24 February 2016 available at http://malawi24.com/2016/02/24/chakhwantha-out-on-bail/
[17] See Section 83 of the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Code (CP&EC), Cap 8:01 of the Laws of Malawi available at https://www.imolin.org/doc/amlid/Malawi/Malawi_Criminal_Procedure_and_Evidence_Code.pdf
[18] Section 13(1) of the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Code (CP&EC), Cap 8:01 of the Laws of Malawi.
[19] ‘Breaking: Police have no evidence of treason by MCP Parliamentarians – IG Kachama’ The Daily Times, 24 February 2016 available at http://www.times.mw/breaking-police-have-no-evidence-of-treason-by-mcp-parliamentarians-ig-kachama/
[20] Ibid
[21] Wanga Gwede ‘No charges of treason for MCP gurus, says Malawi Police IG Kachama’ Nyasatimes, 24 February 2016 available at http://www.nyasatimes.com/2016/02/24/no-charges-of-treason-for-mcp-gurus-says-malawi-police-ig-kachama/
[22] ibid
[23] Ibid
[24] Paida Kadzakumanja ‘Parliament adjourn the house amid security concerns’ The Nation, 24 January 2016 available at http://mwnation.com/parliament-adjourns-amid-security-concerns/
[25] Mphatso Nkhoma, ‘Govt assures immunity of MPs from arrests at Malawi Parliament’ Nyasatimes, 25 February 2016 available at http://www.nyasatimes.com/2016/02/25/govt-assures-immunity-of-mps-from-arrests-at-malawi-parliament/
[26] Lameck Masina, 'Malawi Government faulted over Arrest of Coup Suspects' Voice of America, 26 February 2016 available at http://www.voanews.com/content/malawi-government-faulted-over-arrests-of-coup-suspects/3209056.html 

Tuesday, 16 February 2016

CONFERRING OF THE TITLE OF SENIOR COUNSEL IN MALAWI

By Mfundisi, 16 February 2015

The President has appointed several legal practitioners and some judges as senior counsel. Congratulations have been offered while others have raised eyebrows and even questioned why ABC has not been so honoured. This write-up is an attempt by your Mfundisi to shine some line of what this is all about. The title of Senior Counsel (SC) is usually regarded as the highest honour that a practising lawyer achieve on the bar. It is a colonial relic which came with the English Legal System. In England the title is Queen’s Counsel (QC) when there is a female monarch.

APPOINTMENT OF SENIOR COUNSEL
Under Section 89(1)(c), the President has the power to confer honours. The conferment of an SC-ship is an honour. But it is not just an ordinarily honour; it has the status of uplifting the person honoured to the top layer of the legal profession. In terms of order, SCs rank only second to the 2 Law Officers: the Attorney General and Solicitor General respectively. It means that when an SC appears for trial; other lawyers have to give way to the SC to plead his or her case before the court first. They have the right of way, so to speak. After they are appointed, the legalese is they have ‘taken silk’. They are the only ones authorised to wear silk and beautified gowns in court to show their seniority. Gowns, another colonial relic? But that is the subject for another day. 

In terms of process, this is guided by’ Guidelines for the Appointment of Senior Counsel.’ They are not law but just guidelines. However, they are the ones that usually are followed during the processing of applications for senior counsel. According to the Guidelines, one has to apply to be considered for this honour.

Now others, yours truly have question why people have to apply to be honoured. Ordinarily it should be one’s own peers who should recommend such honour. However, the current practice is that one has to apply and motivate the application with justification as to why one deserves to be honoured with the title of SC. This is usually through a 750 word self-assessment ‘essay’.

The general requirements of the Guidelines are that to be eligible for appointment as Senior Counsel, an applicant :
  1. must be a legal practitioner who has exercised, and is entitled to exercise, full rights of audience and appears regularly in the Malawi Supreme Court of Appeal, High Court of Malawi and the courts subordinate to the High Court of Malawi.
  2. should regularly practise in non-contentious fields of the law.
This therefore means only lawyers who are practising the law in courts, among other things can really qualify. The minimum period of practice is 15 years.

The applications are vetted by an Advisory Committee. The first Advisory Committee in the post-one era dispensation was appointed by Bakili Muluzi in 1999 on the recommendation of the Attorney General and comprised:
  • Attorney General (Chair)
  • Chief Justice
  • Solicitor General
  • Chairman (now President) of the Law Society
  • One Senior Counsel
As far as I am aware there have been no changes to the composition of the Advisory Committee.

AUTOMATIC QUALIFICATION
The following public offices automatically qualify for appointment as Senior Counsel:
(a) Chief Justice of Malawi;
(b) Judge of the Malawi Supreme Court of Appeal;
(c) Attorney General;
(d) Solicitor General

The Guidelines say this is in recognition of the fact that the Chief Justice and the Judges of the Supreme Court of Appeal sit on the most superior court in the land and that the Attorney General and the Solicitor General are the Law Officers of the Government. In addition, the Attorney General is the principal legal advisor to the Government and head of the Malawi Bar and is deputized by the Solicitor General.

For an Attorney General or a Solicitor General to qualify as Public Officers, they must have served continuously for a period of at least two years.

I personally must admit that I have problems in conferring the title of SC to a judicial officer while they are serving as such. To me it is not even an honour. You cannot honour a member of the bench with a title coveted by members of the bar. Lost in translation? In the legal profession in Malawi, if one chooses to practice the law; then one looks at two parallel streams: the bar and the bench. Unless one becomes a law officer (Attorney General or Solicitor General) the pinnacle of the bar is being conferred with the honour of SC. For the bench the pinnacle is becoming judge really. Being justice of appeal is the next logical step but does not to me amount to a paradigm shift. The appointee is still first and foremost a judge. Being Chief Justice is of course the highest in the pecking order. But the person is still a judge first and foremost. When a legal practitioner is conferred SC; sirens blow. It is the big thing. When a person is appointed judge, sirens blow. It is the big thing. But when a judge is made SC, I fail to see how sirens will blow. Yes they may be some horns blowing, but more like of a baritone order. Therefore trying to combine honours of one strand and throwing them into the parallel one is something I still cannot get my head around. But maybe I am old school. And the fault can never be with the recipient of the honour. To them it is theirs to cherish; one that will live on forever.

Applications for SC are made to the Attorney General (AG) in Lilongwe between January and June of every year. Before forwarding the application to the Advisory Committee, the AG will solicit written comments of consultees. The current list of Consultees from whom written comments maybe received comprises:
  1. Judges of the Malawi Supreme Court of Appeal.
  2. Judges of the High Court.
  3. The Registrar of the High Court.
  4. At least three practising Senior Counsel.
  5. The Dean of the Law Faculty.
Apart from this list, the Law Society is also usually consulted.

THE 2016 LIST OF APPOINTEES

The President has appointed the following:

CATEGORY A: Legal Practitioners
  • Hon Samuel Tembenu (Minister of Justice and Constitutional Affairs)
  • Mr Kalekeni Kaphale (Attorney General)
  • Mr Alan Chinula of William Faulkner
  • Mr Mayer Chisanga of Chisanga & Tomoka
  • Mr Patrice Nkhono of Mbendera, Nkhono & Asociates
CATEGORY B: Justices of Appeal
  • Justice Anaclet Chipeta
  • Justice Lovemore Chikopa
  • Justice Frank Kapanda
  • Justice Dunstan Mwaungulu
CATEGORY C: Law Officers
  • Dr Janet Banda, Solicitor General and Secretary to Justice
Now you will note above that although Mr Kalekeni Kaphale is a law officer, he has been appointed as a legal practitioner. I have it on good authority that he recused himself in this process and made the application as a legal practitioner. There is nothing in the Guidelines against this. Mr Kaphale could have waited for his tenure to clock 2 years (which is just a couple of months away) for automatic appointment. He chose, wisely in my view, to be appointed in his own right. You will also note that the list does not include Justice Anthony Kamanga, SC. The reason is simple. Justice Kamanga was appointed SC before he was appointed a judge.

For me, looking at this list I would say that all these honours are long long overdue. These are legal practitioners with an average of some 25 years of practice. They ought to have been honoured almost a decade ago! But as I said earlier it also raises an issue that I hold as part of the old school. Should they even have applied? Why should they not just be honoured by the peers? And why does it take so long? I am aware of some other legal practitioners who also deserve this honour but who being old school like me, may have thought that it was not right that they actually apply to be honoured.

But that said, we must not take away the spotlight from where it has shone. These deserving legal practitioners and judges deserve to be congratulated; each and every one of them. Mighty legal luminaries they all are.

Halala!